Fight around trees or another solid obstacle instead of open ground. Keep the pufferfish following a wide circle, shoot when the obstacle creates separation and move before it closes the gap. In co-op, the targeted player runs while teammates fire from different angles.
Recommended preparation
- Clear ordinary creatures from the area.
- Choose two or three trees that form a repeatable outer loop.
- Bring food and enough ammunition for a long fight.
- Use an Uzi or other mobile ranged weapon if you need to fire while moving.
- Use a shotgun only when you can create a deliberate close opening.
- Decide who will pick up the fin or trophy after the kill.
Solo fight route
- Start near the outside of the tree cluster, not in the middle.
- Let the pufferfish commit to your side of the obstacle.
- Turn around the tree and create a short line of sight.
- Fire during that gap; stop before it reaches your new position.
- Continue around the next tree rather than reversing into the boss.
- Heal only after solid cover breaks the direct route.
The goal is not to outrun the boss forever. The trees repeatedly convert a straight charge into a longer path, creating small safe damage windows.
Co-op plan
- The player being chased stays on the outer loop and focuses on survival.
- Other players spread out; do not follow directly behind the runner.
- Shoot from the side while the boss is committed to the runner.
- Call out when attention changes so the new target can take over the route.
- Keep one player ready to collect the distinctive drop.
Why attempts fail
- Fighting in open ground and relying only on sprinting.
- Reversing direction into the pufferfish.
- Reloading while the boss has a straight path.
- Grouping every co-op player around the lure.
- Emptying the wallet on new gear and arriving without healing or ammunition.
Finish the quest correctly
After the fight, pick up the distinct fin or bone-shaped trophy before handling ordinary meat. Carry it directly to the quest giver and confirm the objective changes. Use Island Progression if the hand-in does not register.
Sources
- How to Fish on Steam — Dazed Games / Valve — https://store.steampowered.com/app/4001890/How_to_Fish/ — official bosses, equipment and co-op features.
- How to Fish General Discussions — Steam Community / Valve — https://steamcommunity.com/app/4001890/discussions/ — tree-route, Uzi, shotgun, co-op and trophy reports.